LiveThursday · 29 October 2026Vol. VIII · No. 302
Bangalore
26°C · Clear26°C
Thu, 29 Oct
Latest
Sports

The intricate web Man City spun to con the Premier League

The 40-page document which confirmed Manchester City were found guilty of inflating sponsorship income makes fascinating reading. Here's what it sets out.

"To cheat, trick, deceive, delude with false pretences; to impose upon, take in, hoax."

That is the Oxford English definition of the word "sham".

And that word appears eight times in the independent commission's ruling published on Tuesday, which found Manchester City guilty of all charges related to serious breaches of financial rules, and all but one in relation to a failure to co-operate with the investigation.

The 40-page document makes fascinating reading.

It catalogues how the club's owners, Abu Dhabi United Group, knew from the 2009-10 season that there would be major overspends if the club was to reach the level they wanted to get to.

So, the ruling says, City found a way to boost sponsorship income. Season, after season, after season.

For nine seasons, in fact.

The report shows how the club's owners were topping up the value of the deals.

The so-called Disguised Funding Scheme is the central plank in a series of charges that Manchester City have been found guilty of by the Premier League.

This scheme managed to hide more than £830m of sponsorship funding, while other devices hid £90m in expenses.

We break down the key findings from the document.

The problem became apparent very quickly for the new owners

Manchester City were bought by Abu Dhabi investors in 2008 but, the document says, their predicament had become clear from the start of the 2009-10 season.

These were ambitious new owners who did not just want the club to be competitive. They wanted to have the best players and be winners.

That was not going to be possible without spending more money. And lots of it.

Total losses for the 2009-10 campaign were going to exceed what was, at that time, the record single-season financial loss by a Premier League member club. That was Chelsea FC in 2006, of £140m.

According to the ruling, that was a record that the City owners were adamant the club should not break

The club knew they would likely continue to suffer large losses for at least the following five seasons.

This was when both Uefa and the Premier League were about to bring in financial fair play rules.

This was clearly going to be a problem.

To address this the only option was to significantly increase commercial revenue - and reduce the reliance on their owners.

Sham contracts and the disguised funding scheme

In early 2010, Manchester City took the first steps to get the additional funding into the club.

The intricate web Man City spun to con the Premier League

City would enter into sponsorship agreements which were record amounts and were significantly above fair market value.

It is referred to as the 'disguised funding scheme'.

This is how it worked, according to the ruling.

The sponsorship deals were split into two parts: a base fee, and a tagged sum.

The sponsors would pay the base fee.

And the club's owners would pay the tagged sum.

Ergo, the sponsors would not have to pay the full value of the contract. The club's owners would pay the vast majority, which enabled them to invest in players.

This, the document states, "gave the misleading impression to third parties (including regulators and its auditors) in its financial statements and any required FFP returns that its commercial revenues from sponsorship agreements were far, far greater than was in fact the case".

But the club also knew they had to be nimble.

From time to time the disguised funding scheme would be tweaked to "assist with continued concealment" and "reduce the likelihood of difficult questions being asked".

What did this all mean in reality?

Commercial income from sponsors totalled £949.94m in the seasons from 2009-10 to 2017-18.

The ruling says only £119.25 million represented base fees.

A total of £830.69 million represented tagged sums - the amount paid by the club's owners.

Man City have denied the claims and say the Premier League had misunderstood the sponsorship agreements.

However, the panel said it "rejected that explanation as untrue".

It said it was "concocted well after the event in an attempt to obscure and conceal the realities of the disguised funding scheme".

An example given of the disguised funding scheme in action: plugging an unexpected shortfall in May 2013.

Less than a week before the end of that 2012-13 financial year the club knew they were £9.9m short of complying with Uefa's financial rules.

In a matter of days, without sponsors even being approached, a number of modified sponsor agreements were generated which increased recorded sponsorship fees to pay bonuses for events that had already taken place and to pay for a US tour.

Related in Sports

Latest Across Vijaya Chronicle

In setback to BJP, Congress wins Nagpur MLC seat
Politics

In setback to BJP, Congress wins Nagpur MLC seat

Congress wins Nagpur MLC seat, defeating BJP, as Abhijeet Wanjari secures 67,231 votes to Kohale’s 63,960 in a tight race.

The Hindu29 Oct
Traders seek action against street vendors, encroachments in Dharwad
Politics

Traders seek action against street vendors, encroachments in Dharwad

Traders claims that street vendors are hampering the movement of customers, and hurting the business of local shopkeepers and hotel owners who pay rent, taxes, and licence fees.

The Hindu29 Oct
Telangana SIR: Form-6 rejections and Form-7 deletions unusually high during pre-SIR period
Politics

Telangana SIR: Form-6 rejections and Form-7 deletions unusually high during pre-SIR period

Telangana SIR highlights unusually high Form-6 rejections and Form-7 deletions before SIR, risking many genuine electors from final rolls.

The Hindu29 Oct
Cyclone Arnab: Corporator candidates shifts focus to relief works from electioneering in Vizag
Politics

Cyclone Arnab: Corporator candidates shifts focus to relief works from electioneering in Vizag

Cyclone Arnab shifts Vizag election focus to relief, with candidates aiding restoration efforts and coordinating relief in affected wards.

The Hindu29 Oct
Revenue authorities told to examine records in 13-year-old land dispute involving 70 acres of government land in Kalaburagi district
Politics

Revenue authorities told to examine records in 13-year-old land dispute involving 70 acres of government land in Kalaburagi district

The tahsildar was cautioned that failure to comply with the Commission’s directions could invite action under Section 20(2) of the Right to Information Act, 2005.

The Hindu29 Oct
High-speed train crash kills at least 68 people in Spain
World

High-speed train crash kills at least 68 people in Spain

The crash, between a moving train and another that was stopped further up the track, was caused by an "inexplicable" error, the transport minister said.

BBC News28 Oct